Josh shares what went into the All That Echoes Target exclusive while in target. He then proceeded to shop for another hour. Watch the video above or click here.You can get All That Echoes from Target by clicking here.
I have been a member of FOJG for 4 years & have ordered and received my fan edition of 'All That Echoes' which I absolutely love (although the package isn't as good as the 'Illuminations' one). I am annoyed by the Target edition having more tracks, and the HSN edition having the 'Making of...' DVD and feel that Josh is not being fair to his loyal fans, but I guess that's marketing. I WOULD BE WILLING TO BUY the additional editions but my problem is that because I live in the UK I CAN'T! Neither Target nor HSN deliver outside the USA. So basically, I'm STUFFED, and not happy!
I get that music business decisions need to be made. i just would have liked to know beforehand. I would have still bought the "special" fan club version- but I wouldn't have bought 2 at that price for fewer tracks. I will be going to Taget to get 2 of the other version. I have been a member for 9 years, too, and I do feel a little slighted.
Actually there have always been additional editions, and the foreign releases often have a different added track, it's the way the music industry works. It costs a pittance to join this club and you do get special treats, first looks, videos, first shot at appearances and tour dates. It reflects poorly on us as a club when people complain and whine and carry on when they don't get ALL the goodies because they're in the club. He's had a deal with Target for the last 2 or 3 CDs. I was surprised we didn't get the 'making of' dvd also, we always have, but that doesn't mean we should 'expect' it and be nasty if you're disappointed. He's a performing artist, he loves his fans, how about a little love going the other way?
The "special" fan edition cost me, with shipping charges,
Wow. I cannot believe some of the comments! Believe it or not, not ALL of his biggest supporters are members of this fan club. Why should others who don't have the extra money to join this club be punished and miss out on the extras? I agree that the FOJG edition should have as much material as the Target edition. However, to act as though you are "entitled" to it is a little snotty... Because members get other benefits to make them feel "special" and "appreciated". I just joined this super exclusive club last night, despite my being a fan for over a decade now, thinking it would be fun but these comments are super disappointing. I can understand being disappointed because its not what you've come to expect from past experiences... But be a little excited and grateful that you even have the album! Sheesh. I loveeeeee the album SO much and was delighted Falling Slowly was included <3 Another job well done!!
SOME PEOPLE ARE NEVER HAPPY. I DONT CARE HOW MANY VERSIONS I PURCHASE TO HAVE IT ALL, ITS WORTH IT ANYTHING HE SINGS IS AMAZING.
dude, some may think of this as a sell ot, and just a bit over orchestrated
WHAT IS GOING ON??? I have bought the FOJG Special Fan Club Editions of ALL of Josh's studio albums and they have always come with material in them that the general public doesn't have access to; ie. extra bonus tracks plus the DVD of the making of the album. No other place has ever been allowed to have special editions/special material that we get. We pay to be in this fan club. I can't believe that we didn't get the making of the album DVD nor the extra track on the Target album, and I can't believe there are so many editions of this album. I joined this fan club not long after it was started those many years ago and stay in it because we are supposed to get special things for being in the fan club. Also, those of us who have been in the fan club for as long as I have feel we are Josh's core fans who helped him get his start in show business. We should be treated better than this. What's going to happen next--are we going to be denied first pick at concert tickets for Josh's tours? If that happens, I don't what I will do. I have always gotten my tour tickets through the fan club presales and been gotten good seats at his concerts because of it. Us FOJG members need to be appreciated properly.
I didn't plan it this way, but I've ended up with several versions. But hey! I wouldn't have it any other way. I've always loved Josh's version of Play Me and his beautiful new song Grazie brought tears to my eyes when I first heard it.
I can give a couple of my friends a nice present - they'll love it.
I'm way over budget, but when it comes to Josh, food for the soul is more important than food on the table!
The best thing about being in the Fan Club is that I've just managed to get my tickets to one of the concerts in Australia and I'm over the moon at the prospect of seeing Josh in person for the very first time. I've never ordered through the Club before and this is certainly the way to go.
so much for ordering the "special" fan club edition. what a ripoff. the least that josh should do is to give us all who preordered the hsn dvd and the target 4th track. this is a slap in the face to all of us who thought we were really getting something special, only to find something more was going to be out there. so disappointed., this has taked away some of the excitement of the new album.
I was disappointed to find out that the fan version has less songs than Target version! I would have waited and just gone to Target had I known. Absolutely LOVE the new album though:-)
All That Echoes Album was a MASTERPIECE !!!!!!
I love the new album soooo very much !!!!
Love you soooo very much !!!
Best wishes from IRAN !!!
ANOTHER VERSION !!!!! What is the point of being in a fanclub I thought we would at least have the best deal. Will seriously reconsider joining next year if this is going to happen again.
Thanks so much for sharing it and all.. good luck.. cariños and besitos.JS
I wouldn't buy three different versions of an album from anyone else, but I've got my FOJG version in hand, the HSN version with the DVD coming, and the Target version ordered. I had to have that fourth bonus song! #worthit
@MichaelGladis "don't let the name fool ye. Ain't nothin' glad about him."
35678 members. • Join the community